Saturday, August 31, 2013

Yes and yes!

Here's Digby's wonderful view on today's events....

Just a note to say that while I'm glad the president has decided to get congressional authorization --- it is a necessary concession to democratic principles --- it does not change my calculus about the wisdom of bombing Syria. I've thought a lot about this since the war with Iraq, when I made arguments repeatedly about "norms" and just war theory and constitutional requirements and the necessity of UN approval.  And I realized later that it was all a dodge on a certain level.  Yes, international norms are important as are our adherence to treaties and constitutional obligations.  But they don't trump the fact that it is unwise to take certain actions even if all those conditions are met. I do not think it makes sense to bomb Syria on the merits, regardless of who approves it.  I think the US is needlessly running into a buzzsaw and may very likely make things worse. In my view, the correct approach for the US is energetic diplomacy with an eye toward pulling Russia and China away from their positions and getting the other Middle Eastern countries to put pressure on Assad. We have become dependent on the idea that bombing and killing is the only way to affect change despite the evidence that it doesn't work any better than using other approaches. The US has a lot of power and influence aside from an ability to launch cruise missiles.  I think we've gotten tremendously uncreative. Anyway, that's my story and I'm sticking to it.

7 comments:

  1. Agree. Thank you. Now let's just see what they do. I keep thinking of that line, "When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks to Digby, too, from whose blog I got this.

      Delete
  2. Anonymous8:43 AM

    Oh, gee, ME. This early in the morning I cannot read orange on white text - had to copy to a Word file and change the color.

    Acts of war beget acts of war. Brer Rabbit would have been better off to have kept his fists and feet to himself.
    Cop Car

    ReplyDelete
  3. Cop Car: awk. the whole "orange" text is a link to Hullabaloo by Digby. time to change the color scheme of my blog, i think, so that links don't turn out orange on white. so sorry. never noticed that before.

    ReplyDelete
  4. back to the green & blue with what looks like dark red (alizarin crimson?) and orange highlights in the text. more readable?? most of the other colors use grey as the highlights for links, etc., and i can't see those very well even myself.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anonymous10:12 AM

    XE--Had I hovered the cursor over the text I might have been able to read it before. Surprisingly, yes, orange on green is more readable, thanks.
    Cop Car

    ReplyDelete
  6. If only common sense could prevail. Sigh.

    ReplyDelete

XE welcomes your comments. Spam and offensive material will not be posted and will be deleted.

Thanks for your patience and cooperation.