Three years of torture* is enough punishment. Why are we being so vindictive toward him? The real scoundrels of the Iraq war are walking around free, smiling, acting like big shots. Manning has helped us see the real cost of this war. For once, the NYT and I agree.
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/22/opinion/bradley-mannings-sentence-is-excessive.html
Addendum: http://www.juancole.com/2013/08/36925.html
Cole's last paragraph:
*Well, depends on what you consider torture.Manning was tortured for nearly a year*, and that should have been sentence enough. Without him, we might not even know about the Panopticon of total suveillance in which we are living. Manning helped spark a new civil rights movement. He deserves Obama’s Nobel Peace Prize in a way the president does not. [Italics mine]
The following paragraph is from The Nation in an article by Chase Madar.
Update, 8/22/2013: Yesterday, Bradley Manning was sentenced to 35 years in prison. Today, Chelsea Elizabeth Manning announced through her lawyer that she will live the rest of her life as a woman, and we have amended our comment from yesterday in conformity with who she is. Chelsea Manning will most likely be imprisoned at Fort Leavenworth, which like all other US military prisons and many civilian ones, does not provide hormone therapy or gender transition surgery to transgender prisoners. These policies should be reversed immediately.God love ya, Chelsea! You're one hell of a brave woman, a true American heroine.
Yes...and yes. We live in troubling times. Sure, we always have but now we know more--and need to--about more of our and their troubles.
ReplyDelete